The city of Oakland, California, has announced a “guaranteed income” project to support local low-income families – but curiously, poor white families won’t be included, leading many to slam the move as racist.
Announced earlier this month, the ‘Oakland Resilient Families’ plan was described by the mayor’s office as one of America’s “largest efforts to determine the effectiveness of monthly unconditional payments” aimed at helping people “overcome economic instability.”
Supported by the Family Independence Initiative and Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, the scheme would see 600 families in the city getting an unconditional $500 per month, for at least 18 months.
Families with at least one child under 18 and a total income of less than or equal to $59,000 per year for a family of three can apply, the announcement says, adding that half the spots would be specifically reserved for families of three with a total income of $30,000 per year or lower. The families will be chosen on a “randomly selected” basis.
Yet, there’s one issue about the otherwise charitable endeavor that has sparked uproar on social media: Poor white people may not apply. The announcement from the mayor’s office explicitly states the project is only open to Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC).
Mayor Libby Schaaf said the scheme is not just a step to fight poverty, but intended as a blow against “systemic” racism, seemingly explaining why white families are not included.
“The poverty we all witness today is not a personal failure, it is a systems failure,” Schaaf said. “I’m proud to work with such committed local partners to build a new system that can help undo centuries of economic and racial injustice, and point us all toward a more just society.”
Oakland authorities justified the decision by pointing to the city’s Equity Index, which showed that white households earn more than any other, on average, earning almost three times as much as African American ones.
The same report also said that 26% of African Americans in Oakland live at or below the poverty rate as well as almost 22% of Latinos. It added, though, that more than eight percent of the city’s white people are living at or below the poverty line.
Schaaf’s decision received instant pushback on social media, with many branding it “racist” and some even suggesting suing authorities over it.
“Let’s fight racism with even worse racism!”
— George Ivanov (@RavenBeard_PLBG) March 25, 2021
This will only cause more racial division and resentment.
— Cinnamint Patti (@mangosyplatanos) March 25, 2021
One Reddit commenter called it an “explicity racist policy” while others accused the mayor’s office of just “pretending” to care about poverty and criticized the “lottery” principle.
Harmeet Dhillon, a co-chair of the Republican National Lawyers Association, branded the initiative “unconstitutional” and offered her services to any white person “otherwise eligible” for the program, who would like to “challenge it in court.”
This is unconstitutional. If an otherwise eligible person wants to challenge it in court, know that there are lawyers who would take the case. Oakland will exclude white families living in poverty from $500 checks https://t.co/i6ewbamphn via @MailOnline
— Harmeet K. Dhillon (@pnjaban) March 25, 2021
Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!